Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop - Revision history

Neilotte: /* Draft Agenda, Wednesday, July 18 */

2018-07-18T12:24:01Z

Draft Agenda, Wednesday, July 18

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:24, 18 July 2018
Line 28:		Line 28:
	3. Coffee Break (10:30 - 11:00am)		3. Coffee Break (10:30 - 11:00am)

	4. ~~Where are we now? Summarizing where we are now based on~~ the ~~earlier part. Starting of the roadmap discussion.~~ (11 - 11:30am)		4. Report from the Governance Board (Jim Wilson) (11 - 11:30am)

	5. ~~Report from~~ the ~~Governance Board (Jim Wilson)~~ (11:30 - 12:30pm)		5. Where are we now? Summarizing where we are now based on the earlier part. Starting of the roadmap discussion. (11:30 - 12:30pm)

	12:30 - 1:30pm Lunch, including discussion on Ontologies for industrial data: is there a convincing business case? introduced by Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)		12:30 - 1:30pm Lunch, including discussion on Ontologies for industrial data: is there a convincing business case? introduced by Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)

Neilotte at 19:53, 13 July 2018

2018-07-13T19:53:30Z

Show changes

Phismith: /* The Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop, USA */

2018-07-02T13:46:54Z

The Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop, USA

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:46, 2 July 2018
Line 14:		Line 14:
	''Note'': The workshop requires an $80 registration fee, which covers catering, workspace, and technology for two days. However, there is also an optional multi-course dinner for $40 that may be paid in advance at registration.		''Note'': The workshop requires an $80 registration fee, which covers catering, workspace, and technology for two days. However, there is also an optional multi-course dinner for $40 that may be paid in advance at registration.

			'''[https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/1D_7Y65g8GKmiCThRu9OeBXKWQjyiXso2 Link]''' to conference discussion documents
	*'''For further information please contact [mailto:neilotte@gmail.com Neil Otte]'''		*'''For further information please contact [mailto:neilotte@gmail.com Neil Otte]'''

Neilotte: /* The Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop, USA */

2018-06-28T18:27:20Z

The Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop, USA

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:27, 28 June 2018
Line 8:		Line 8:
	'''Venue''' '''[http://doubletree3.hilton.com/en/hotels/new-york/doubletree-by-hilton-hotel-buffalo-amherst-BUFFLDT/index.html DoubleTree Hotel in Amherst]''' in Buffalo, NY, USA		'''Venue''' '''[http://doubletree3.hilton.com/en/hotels/new-york/doubletree-by-hilton-hotel-buffalo-amherst-BUFFLDT/index.html DoubleTree Hotel in Amherst]''' in Buffalo, NY, USA

	''Note'': To book your stay at the group rate, you may contact the front desk of the hotel directly and say that are coming for the 'Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop taking place July 18th and 19th' or visit [http://doubletree.hilton.com/en/dt/groups/personalized/B/BUFFLDT-TIO-20180718/index.jhtml].		''Note'': To book your stay at the group rate, you may contact the front desk of the hotel directly and say that are coming for the 'Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop taking place July 18th and 19th' or visit the following link: [http://doubletree.hilton.com/en/dt/groups/personalized/B/BUFFLDT-TIO-20180718/index.jhtml].

	'''Registration''' '''[http://www.buffalo.edu/cas/philosophy/events/iof-workshop-2018.html Registration Page]'''		'''Registration''' '''[http://www.buffalo.edu/cas/philosophy/events/iof-workshop-2018.html Registration Page]'''

Neilotte: /* The Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop, USA */

2018-06-28T18:27:00Z

The Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop, USA

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:27, 28 June 2018
Line 8:		Line 8:
	'''Venue''' '''[http://doubletree3.hilton.com/en/hotels/new-york/doubletree-by-hilton-hotel-buffalo-amherst-BUFFLDT/index.html DoubleTree Hotel in Amherst]''' in Buffalo, NY, USA		'''Venue''' '''[http://doubletree3.hilton.com/en/hotels/new-york/doubletree-by-hilton-hotel-buffalo-amherst-BUFFLDT/index.html DoubleTree Hotel in Amherst]''' in Buffalo, NY, USA

	''Note'': To book your stay at the group rate, ~~please~~ contact the front desk of the hotel directly and say that are coming for the 'Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop taking place July 18th and 19th'.		''Note'': To book your stay at the group rate, you may contact the front desk of the hotel directly and say that are coming for the 'Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF) Workshop taking place July 18th and 19th' or visit [http://doubletree.hilton.com/en/dt/groups/personalized/B/BUFFLDT-TIO-20180718/index.jhtml].

	'''Registration''' '''[http://www.buffalo.edu/cas/philosophy/events/iof-workshop-2018.html Registration Page]'''		'''Registration''' '''[http://www.buffalo.edu/cas/philosophy/events/iof-workshop-2018.html Registration Page]'''

Phismith: /* Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19 */

2018-06-22T17:59:21Z

Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:59, 22 June 2018
Line 87:		Line 87:
	17:00 Close		17:00 Close

	~~'''Notes'''~~		----

	~~Johan: 4D does not work with OWL DL. Is IOF tied to OWL DL?~~		==Notes==

	~~Todd~~: IOF ~~intends~~ to ~~use at least~~ OWL ~~and CL, and not necessary limit to these two.~~		:Johan: 4D does not work with OWL DL. Is IOF tied to OWL DL?

	~~Potential clusters of~~ use ~~cases~~		:Todd: IOF intends to use at least OWL and CL, and not necessary limit to these two.

	~~Maintenance planning (any industry specific?) (Melinda)~~		'''Potential clusters of use cases'''

	~~'''Possible ontology modules'''~~		:Maintenance planning (any industry specific?) (Melinda)

	~~Process plan/maintenance plan~~

	~~Time~~

	~~Units~~

	~~Resource/Equipment/Asset~~

	~~Topology/Geolocation~~

	~~Production~~ planning ~~and scheduling of discrete manufacturing~~ (~~Dusan, Peter, Walter~~)

	'''Possible ontology modules'''		'''Possible ontology modules'''

	Process ~~knowledge~~/~~capability~~		:Process plan/maintenance plan

	~~Process~~ plan

	~~Resource/Equipment/Asset~~		:Time

	~~Time~~		:Units

	~~Units~~		:Resource/Equipment/Asset

	Topology/Geolocation		:Topology/Geolocation

	~~Supply chain~~ (~~Farhad Ameri~~)		:Production planning and scheduling of discrete manufacturing (Dusan, Peter, Walter)

	~~Product/Process requirement~~		:Supply chain (Farhad Ameri)

	~~Organization~~/~~Agent~~		:Product/Process requirement

	:~~Could we agree on which module which group will focus on?~~		:Organization/Agent

	:~~How do~~ we ~~deal with modules needed by a~~ group ~~that is to be produced by another group.~~		::Could we agree on which module which group will focus on?

	:~~Could~~ we ~~agree on~~ a ~~common starting point for some of these modules?~~		::How do we deal with modules needed by a group that is to be produced by another group.

			::Could we agree on a common starting point for some of these modules?

	~~'''~~From CHAMP~~'''~~		----
			==From CHAMP==

	1. Review of Use Cases		1. Review of Use Cases

Phismith: /* Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19 */

2018-06-22T17:57:13Z

Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:57, 22 June 2018
Line 85:		Line 85:
	15:00 Roadmap (second round)		15:00 Roadmap (second round)

	'''Notes~~;;;~~		17:00 Close

			'''Notes'''

	Johan: 4D does not work with OWL DL. Is IOF tied to OWL DL?		Johan: 4D does not work with OWL DL. Is IOF tied to OWL DL?

	Todd: IOF intends to use at least OWL and CL, and not necessary limit to ~~this~~ two.		Todd: IOF intends to use at least OWL and CL, and not necessary limit to these two.

	Potential clusters of use cases		Potential clusters of use cases
Line 95:		Line 97:
	Maintenance planning (any industry specific?) (Melinda)		Maintenance planning (any industry specific?) (Melinda)

	Possible ontology modules		'''Possible ontology modules'''

	Process plan/maintenance plan		Process plan/maintenance plan
Line 129:		Line 131:
	Organization/Agent		Organization/Agent

	Could we agree on which module which group will focus on?		:Could we agree on which module which group will focus on?

	How do we deal with modules needed by a group that is to be produced by another group.		:How do we deal with modules needed by a group that is to be produced by another group.

	Could we agree on a common starting point for some of these modules?		:Could we agree on a common starting point for some of these modules?


Line 177:		Line 179:

	• IRI for the IOF.		• IRI for the IOF.

	~~Lunch (12:30 - 1:30)~~

	~~Challenge discussion continued (1:30-2:30pm)~~

	~~Break (2:30-3pm)~~

	~~Roadmap (second round) (3 - 5pm)~~

Phismith: /* Draft Agenda, Wednesday, July 18 */

2018-06-22T17:55:47Z

Draft Agenda, Wednesday, July 18

@@ Line 41: / Line 41: @@
 :00 Technical principles (continued)
-Link to questions will be provided
+:00 Close
-Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19
+:00 Dinner
-Challenges dicussion (8:30-12:30):
+Link to questions will be provided
 == Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19 ==

Phismith: /* Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19 */

2018-06-22T17:54:05Z

Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:54, 22 June 2018
Line 155:		Line 155:

	== Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19 ==		== Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19 ==

			8:00 Arrival

			8:30 Discussion of challenges

			What are the challenges to discuss?

			Use of existing standards.

			How to design IOF ontology by leveraging existing standards which may not be ontology?

			How to design IOF ontology by leveraging existing ontologies?

			10:15 Break

			10:30 Discussion of challenges (continued)

			Ontology merging. Will diversity of ontologies in a particular area be allowed? (Introduced by Barry Smith)

			Diversity of ontologies in IOF.

			Dealing with diversity outside of IOF.

			Ontology Merging: How do we resolve conflicts among ontologies within the IOF? (Introduced by Dimitris Kiritsis)

			Best practices and software environments for collaborative distributed ontology development

			IRI for the IOF

			12:30 Lunch

			13:30 Discussion of challenges (continued)

			14:30 Break

			15:00 Roadmap (second round)

			'''Notes;;;

			Johan: 4D does not work with OWL DL. Is IOF tied to OWL DL?

			Todd: IOF intends to use at least OWL and CL, and not necessary limit to this two.

			Potential clusters of use cases

			Maintenance planning (any industry specific?) (Melinda)

			Possible ontology modules

			Process plan/maintenance plan

			Time

			Units

			Resource/Equipment/Asset

			Topology/Geolocation

			Production planning and scheduling of discrete manufacturing (Dusan, Peter, Walter)

			'''Possible ontology modules'''

			Process knowledge/capability

			Process plan

			Resource/Equipment/Asset

			Time

			Units

			Topology/Geolocation

			Supply chain (Farhad Ameri)

			Product/Process requirement

			Organization/Agent

			Could we agree on which module which group will focus on?

			How do we deal with modules needed by a group that is to be produced by another group.

			Could we agree on a common starting point for some of these modules?


			'''From CHAMP'''

			1. Review of Use Cases

			2. Reports from Domain (Bottom Up) working groups

			3. Report from Top-Down working group

			4. Where are we now?

			5. Roadmap (first round)

			12:00 Lunch, including discussion on Ontologies for industrial data: is there a convincing business case? introduced by Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)

			6. Discussion of Technical Principles

			Example A: Will diversity of ontologies in a particular area be allowed Introduced by Barry Smith (Buffalo)

	Arrival 8:00		Arrival 8:00

Phismith: /* Draft Agenda, Wednesday, July 18 */

2018-06-22T17:48:17Z

Draft Agenda, Wednesday, July 18

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:48, 22 June 2018
Line 22:		Line 22:
	8:30 Use Case Q&A, Buttom-up WGs discussions, Updates from Domain (Bottom Up) working groups, if any. Maybe identifying some requirements		8:30 Use Case Q&A, Buttom-up WGs discussions, Updates from Domain (Bottom Up) working groups, if any. Maybe identifying some requirements

	9:30 Report from Top-Down working group (9:~~30 - 10:30am)~~		9:30 Report from Top-Down working group: Identify technical challenges.

	~~Hope to identify technical challenges.~~		10:30 Coffee Break

	~~4. Coffee Break (10:30 -~~ 11:~~00am)~~		11:00 Where are we now?

	~~5. Where are we now? Summarizing where we are now based on the earlier part. Starting of the roadmap~~ discussion. (~~11 - 11:30am~~)		11:30 Roadmap discussion (first round)

	~~5. Roadmap (first round) (11~~:30 - 12:30pm)		12:30 - 1:30pm Lunch, including discussion:
			*Ontologies for industrial data: is there a convincing business case? introduced by Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)

	12:30 ~~- 1:30pm Lunch, including discussion on Ontologies for industrial data: is there a convincing business case? introduced by Melinda Hodkiewicz~~ (~~University of Western Australia~~)		13:30 Roadmap (second round)

	~~6. Roadmap continued (1~~:30 ~~- 2:30)~~		14:30 Technical principles

	~~7. Technical Principle (2~~:30 ~~- 3:30)~~		15:30 Break

	~~Break 3~~:~~30-4:00pm~~		16:00 Technical principles (continued)

	~~8 Technical principle continued (4:00 - 5:00)~~		Link to questions will be provided

	~~There are~~ questions ~~left in the doc. The focus would~~ be ~~to iron out those questions. Some of them are independent from the challenges.~~

	~~Need a couple of hours.~~

	Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19		Draft Agenda, Thursday, July 19